Comments - What is feminist about outcome harvesting? - Gender and Evaluation2024-03-29T01:49:44Zhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profiles/comment/feed?attachedTo=6606644%3ABlogPost%3A83541&xn_auth=noDear Barbara,
This is in the…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-05-07:6606644:Comment:841702019-05-07T17:46:30.848ZPrakash Kumarhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/PrakashKumar
<p>Dear Barbara, </p>
<h5>This is in the context of outcome method (OM) which lays down changes in behavior of intervention’s direct partner. Here changes are defined as changes in behavior, action and relationship. The method provides a broader sense of understanding in every layer of intervention who is involved as boundary partners and also gradually defined changes markers in three dimensions as expect to see, like to see and love to see. To look forwards in the outcome harvesting (OH)…</h5>
<p>Dear Barbara, </p>
<h5>This is in the context of outcome method (OM) which lays down changes in behavior of intervention’s direct partner. Here changes are defined as changes in behavior, action and relationship. The method provides a broader sense of understanding in every layer of intervention who is involved as boundary partners and also gradually defined changes markers in three dimensions as expect to see, like to see and love to see. To look forwards in the outcome harvesting (OH) method as evaluation focuses on contribution, engagement, participation to see the immediate result of certain intervention in particular period of time. </h5>
<h5>The question will be raised here how the OH is different from OM, Is it same or provides some additional mechanism to examine/ investigate in immediate changes in terms of attitude, action and behavior? Will it be a different level of findings while using these two different methods?</h5> Dear Barbara, congratulations…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-05-07:6606644:Comment:843632019-05-07T16:21:07.192ZFabiola Amarileshttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/FabiolaAmariles
<p><span>Dear Barbara, congratulations on this excellent tribute to Ricardo Wilson-Grau! I am sure he would have enjoyed the way you highlight the important contributions of OH to feminist evaluation.</span></p>
<p><span>I like the way you connect the feminist perspective with the main characteristics of OH; we feminist evaluators need to preserve, promote and apply those links in order to apply the view you express in the blog, with which I agree completely: that “feminist practice can be…</span></p>
<p><span>Dear Barbara, congratulations on this excellent tribute to Ricardo Wilson-Grau! I am sure he would have enjoyed the way you highlight the important contributions of OH to feminist evaluation.</span></p>
<p><span>I like the way you connect the feminist perspective with the main characteristics of OH; we feminist evaluators need to preserve, promote and apply those links in order to apply the view you express in the blog, with which I agree completely: that “feminist practice can be brought to most evaluation approaches”; and that “any evaluation can ask questions of concern to feminism”.</span></p>
<p><span>Thank you for bringing these concepts forward!</span></p>
<p><span>Abrazos (hugs), Fabiola</span></p> Thank you Barbara for this bl…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-05-07:6606644:Comment:843612019-05-07T15:50:52.698ZLyn Messnerhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/LynMessner
<p>Thank you Barbara for this blog. We use outcome mapping quite a bit at EnCompass and are eager to do more in outcome harvesting, and I appreciate how you've outlined the key components of this process while highlighting how and why it's feminist while acknowledging limitations. </p>
<p>Thank you Barbara for this blog. We use outcome mapping quite a bit at EnCompass and are eager to do more in outcome harvesting, and I appreciate how you've outlined the key components of this process while highlighting how and why it's feminist while acknowledging limitations. </p> Nice post Barbara, i got a li…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-05-07:6606644:Comment:843582019-05-07T13:53:47.973ZMary Nderituhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/MaryMuthoniNderitu
<p>Nice post Barbara, i got a little confused at the beginning but am sorted now by all the explanation in this blog post.</p>
<p>Nice post Barbara, i got a little confused at the beginning but am sorted now by all the explanation in this blog post.</p> Hi Barbara, thanks for the po…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-05-07:6606644:Comment:843482019-05-07T09:20:22.886ZIvan Tasichttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/IvanTasic
<p>Hi Barbara, thanks for the post and the attachment. Really useful. Cheers!</p>
<p>Hi Barbara, thanks for the post and the attachment. Really useful. Cheers!</p> Thanks for this clarification…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-04-27:6606644:Comment:841112019-04-27T06:12:50.370ZRanjani K.Murthyhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/RanjaniKMurthy
<p>Thanks for this clarification barbs- is outcome harvesting one way of contribution analysis? Will read up more. I am glad you are working on gender mainstreaming in these- as often we feminists do our own thing, and these approaches continue with theirs</p>
<p>My dad is unwell, at 87. Mustafa and Armaan are fine. Thanks for your annual updates </p>
<p>Thanks for this clarification barbs- is outcome harvesting one way of contribution analysis? Will read up more. I am glad you are working on gender mainstreaming in these- as often we feminists do our own thing, and these approaches continue with theirs</p>
<p>My dad is unwell, at 87. Mustafa and Armaan are fine. Thanks for your annual updates </p> Hi Ranjani !! Fully agree wit…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-04-23:6606644:Comment:838022019-04-23T12:33:31.877ZBarbara Klugmanhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/BarbaraKlugman
<p>Hi Ranjani !! Fully agree with your posts. Also want to note that it is Outcome Mapping, rather than Outcome Harvesting that engages the various activities you mention - outcome maps, boundary partners etc. Outcome Harvesting is used to see what actual outcomes occurred and then explore the contribution of the groups concerned, going backwards in time from the actual outcomes. Although OH drew some of its inspiration from Outcome Mapping, it is not a planning tool, but rather focuses on…</p>
<p>Hi Ranjani !! Fully agree with your posts. Also want to note that it is Outcome Mapping, rather than Outcome Harvesting that engages the various activities you mention - outcome maps, boundary partners etc. Outcome Harvesting is used to see what actual outcomes occurred and then explore the contribution of the groups concerned, going backwards in time from the actual outcomes. Although OH drew some of its inspiration from Outcome Mapping, it is not a planning tool, but rather focuses on actual changes. Hope all's well with you and yours, Barbara</p>
<p></p> Dear Barbara
Thanks
I think…tag:gendereval.ning.com,2019-04-22:6606644:Comment:836872019-04-22T11:04:41.296ZRanjani K.Murthyhttps://gendereval.ning.com/profile/RanjaniKMurthy
<p>Dear Barbara</p>
<p>Thanks </p>
<p>I think both process and outcomes need to reflect a feminist perspective</p>
<p>The process of arrive at outcome maps, definition of boundary partners, and what one would expect to see, like to see and love to see have to reflect a gender-transformative lens . </p>
<p>Not all outcome mapping exercises are feminist, and not all feminist evaluations clearly focus on outcomes and impact </p>
<p>Best</p>
<p>Ranjani</p>
<p> </p>
<p></p>
<p></p>
<p>Dear Barbara</p>
<p>Thanks </p>
<p>I think both process and outcomes need to reflect a feminist perspective</p>
<p>The process of arrive at outcome maps, definition of boundary partners, and what one would expect to see, like to see and love to see have to reflect a gender-transformative lens . </p>
<p>Not all outcome mapping exercises are feminist, and not all feminist evaluations clearly focus on outcomes and impact </p>
<p>Best</p>
<p>Ranjani</p>
<p> </p>
<p></p>
<p></p>